Expert’s Voice: Hotel marketing – what separates winners from losers?
Hotels that boost investment in marketing will prosper when the recovery gathers pace, says Ines Barreiros, ecommerce and digital marketing manager at Guestcentric’s Lab division.
In an economic recession, many hoteliers may be hesitant to risk jeopardising their revenue post-crisis by investing in marketing campaigns. If you are part of this crowd, we have one question: do you want prospective customers to remember you when ‘revenge travel’ strikes?
As our CEO Pedro Colaco says, “hotel marketing is not about selling, but generating demand”. History tells us that periods of low demand give hotels the opportunity to ramp up marketing in preparation for the upturn. When looking back at the crises of the past, it’s important to understand which strategies hotels implemented that ensured a faster and stronger recovery. This will ultimately help you make the right business decisions today, for a profitable tomorrow.
In this article, we look at a study conducted during the crisis of 2008, and what differentiated the winners from the losers in the upturn that followed.
What does history tell us about hotel marketing during economic recovery?
As is the case today, hotels and the wider hospitality industry suffered dearly in the crisis of 2008. Most of the developed economies (particularly in North America, South America and Europe) felt the greatest impact, falling into severe, sustained recession.
But if there is anything the hospitality industry can learn from economic recession history, hotels that made strategic decisions and marketing investments emerged as winners in the long term. To back up this assertion, we analyse a study by Cornell Hospitality about hotel performance during the crisis of 2008 to 2009.
The research, published in the article ‘Winners and Losers During the Great Recession: The Positive Impact of Marketing Expenditures’, revealed what strategies enabled some hotels to emerge stronger from the crisis in the long term. The study analysed 416 US hotels (a mix of independent, branded hotels, extended-stay properties and luxury hotels), and revealed a group of 100 winners to 106 losers (and 210 average performers), based on financial performance during the economic downturn.
In 2009, during the worst year of the recession, both the winners and losers in this study suffered declines in occupancy and ADR [average daily rate] (as did all hotels). But when analysing key metrics such as ADR, RevPAR [revenue per available room], occupancy and NOIPAR [net operating income per available room), the winners significantly outperformed the losers and were better positioned for the upturn and pent-up demand that followed. In fact, the losers group suffered a 43% decline in NOIPAR compared with a 27% drop for the winners.
Although both groups reduced costs (in equal measures) for room expenses, administrative and general expenses, maintenance expenses, and utility expenses, the losers group made one notable cost reduction: marketing investment. The winners group, on the other hand, actually increased marketing investment during the recession.
How increased marketing investment distinguished the winners from losers in crisis
The study revealed how increased marketing investment served as a primary driver for revenue and profit during times of economic crisis. There was a strong correlation between marketing expenditures and business performance, with greater investment resulting in higher room revenues and NOI [net operating income]. The results also highlighted the importance of different marketing efforts, including personalised sales efforts. Ecommerce, advertising and loyalty programmes helped hotels emerge stronger from the crisis and recover faster.
Analysing the level of investment toward the specific marketing sub-areas covered in the study, researchers also found that hotels from the winners group ramped up complimentary gifts, services and local promotions. Hotels from the losers group, however, reduced investment in these areas.
Another major finding of this study was that hotels that didn’t dramatically drop the prices performed largely better than the ones with heavy discounts. Price discount does not always work during recessionary periods because of demand inelasticity, which will result in revenue decline because reductions and price promotions are insufficient to stimulate demand to generate higher revenues.
Although the current economic downturn differs significantly from 2008, it is still essential for hotels to be top of mind for consumers. During low levels of demand and commercial activity, hotels need to use their time wisely to generate awareness and reach guests directly, thus positioning for faster and stronger recovery when the upturn comes.
In 2008, all hotels also suffered huge declines in occupancy, revenue and lowered ADR. What separated the winners from the losers was the level of readiness to stay the course on marketing expenses. This ultimately paid off and led to better results in all KPIs [key performance indicators] analysed in the study. So before reducing marketing costs, hotel managers should assess whether maintaining or increasing investment could both generate revenue and profit when consumer demand returns to pre-Covid levels.
Hotels that maintain price and invest in building a strong brand through marketing during periods of low demand can expect to achieve greater customer satisfaction and loyalty, which will ultimately translate to higher revenue and consequently more profitability in the upturn.
But although research shows that those who invest more in marketing emerge stronger from an economic crisis, hotels need to invest wisely. Before jumping into new sales and marketing campaigns, hoteliers need to first understand the current market demands, define the hotel’s business goals, and evaluate the cost of marketing efforts versus the return.
This is an edited version of an article that appeared on the GuestCentric blog.
Ecommerce and digital marketing manager at Guestcentric’s Lab division
Ines Barreiros is an ecommerce and digital marketing manager at Guestcentric's Lab division, a service that specialises in maximising hotels' online presence and direct revenue. Her extensive hospitality knowledge and digital expertise have been instrumental in helping numerous hotels across Europe.
Deep dive with Yuthachai Charanachitta, CEO, Onyx Hospitality Group
Yuthachai Charanachitta outlined why aparthotels and conversions will be particularly prevalent in the company’s plans. What does Onyx’s overall hotel pipeline look like and how has this progressed over recent years? Onyx is planning to open at least 11 properties...
Marriott undertakes senior leadership reshuffle
The changes start at the top, with CEO, Anthony ‘Tony’ Capuano also taking on the hotel group’s president function after the previous incumbent, Stephanie Linnartz, stepped down to become CEO of sportswear brand, Under Armour. Development head The existing chief...
Harrison design agency appoints new global CEO
This announcement marks a significant change in the senior strategy and leadership team of the 1989-founded Harrison agency. A new era for the design company This month, Philip Harrison stepped up following the past 34 years of success to become chairman of the...
Deep dive with Ben Harper, group MD at Watergate Bay Hotel, Beach Retreats and Another Place
Ben Harper’s brief covers the group’s flagship Watergate Bay Hotel in Cornwall, self-catering line Beach Retreats and Another Place, The Lake - a lifestyle hospitality hotel on the shores of Ullswater in the Lake District. Aparthotel experience With a background in...
London hotel group promotes senior executive to CEO
He first joined the business as chief financial officer in 2019, leading the group’s finance, procurement and IT functions through a period of significant change encompassing the covid-19 impact and the UK’s cost of living crisis. Senior level experience Taylor has...
Deep dive with Scott Socha, group president, Delaware North
Scott Socha detailed the firm's latest developments, including the acquisition of the 322-key Best Western Premier Grand Canyon Squire Inn in Tusayan, Arizona, which is being renamed Squire Resort at the Grand Canyon, before transitioning to the Best Western Signature...